Go Back   David Icke's Official Forums > Main Forums > The Global Awakening

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 23-02-2018, 08:04 PM   #581
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
so you didn't answer the question, and made a pathetic excuse.

What is the oxygen that fuels the left I wonder ?

Of course you would never answer that.

You only get over analytical when your side is under fire, when it comes to attacking others its straight up black and white narratives.
what fuels the left?

so at the moment there is poverty which was created as part of 'austerity' which was imposed after the government used public money to bail out the rothschild cabal banks so that the global investors who were the creditors of those banks ie the rothschild cabal were basically handed billions of dollars of taxpayers money

so poverty created by the central banking cabal is a big factor

but on top of that the cabal is also fueling the left with simplified narratives that blame white people for the crimes of the rothschild cabal

also flooding in lots of unskilled and poorly educated immigrants increases the base of disgruntled and poor people who can then be mobilised by the left
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act

Last edited by iamawaveofthesea; 23-02-2018 at 08:05 PM.
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:07 PM   #582
tinfoil hat
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2016
Posts: 2,004
Likes: 1,235 (714 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
Young Americans Foundation, spending millions to push right wing agendas and ideas in universities


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young_...27s_Foundation


And why does it need to only be taught in school ?

Ever heard of Social media, internet, TV, radio.

Its being pushed en masse throughout society.
Teaching conservative values is in no way anything at all like teaching an end to whiteness.
And frankly, I wouldn't agree with it if it was teaching an end to blackness, its only you who seems to have no problem with teachers teaching genocide is ok, as long as its to whites.
In fact you defend it and say it isn't happening, when you are in no position to know that.
Its all fake, with no proof.
But don't you dare teach folk that abortion is wrong!!
FFS how obviously racist you are Vancity.
You are the divide.
You are the victim.
Likes: (1)
tinfoil hat is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:09 PM   #583
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

conservatism is basically about values like family, hard work and being law abiding

its foundations are built on christianity and the free markets which allow individual endevour, sponteneity and creativity

this is why the cabal hate christianity and the free markets

its also why the cabal don't want the conservatives to own guns because they don't want free anything and don't want people to be able to protect their freedoms
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act

Last edited by iamawaveofthesea; 23-02-2018 at 08:09 PM.
Likes: (1)
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:25 PM   #584
vancity eagle
Banned
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Posts: 10,492
Likes: 4,419 (2,496 Posts)
Default

[QUOTE]
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamawaveofthesea View Post

so the prejudice of some white people towards blacks in pandering to stereotypes of blacks all being social welfare depedents is not really too high on my lists of concerns regarding the el-ite plan to create the NWO

I don't see how that is going to really drive their agenda forward
translation: white people being racist isn't a problem, its a very small problem and isn't in any way being used to move the NWO forward.

Quote:
However if they flood lots of hispanics into the country and then mobilise those people and black people behind a manufactured crusade against a perceived bogeyman of 'hetero-capitalistic, white-maleness' then i think those people could easily be duped as part of that movement to throw their weight behind issues the cabal want pushed through such as open borders and gun control

I'm a big picture thinker vancity
translation: but the real problem is black and brown people, and their racism IS A PROBLEM.

the big picture is black and brown racism, not white racism.


DUDE YOU ARE JUST A RACIST, PLAIN AND SIMPLE. None of your ridiculous spin can prove otherwise.

Last edited by vancity eagle; 23-02-2018 at 08:27 PM.
vancity eagle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:28 PM   #585
tinfoil hat
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2016
Posts: 2,004
Likes: 1,235 (714 Posts)
Default

It didn't need translating Vancity, it was in plain simple English.

Last edited by tinfoil hat; 23-02-2018 at 08:28 PM.
tinfoil hat is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:33 PM   #586
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
translation: white people being racist isn't a problem, its a very small problem and isn't in any way being used to move the NWO forward.

translation: but the real problem is black and brown people, and their racism IS A PROBLEM.

the big picture is black and brown racism, not white racism.

DUDE YOU ARE JUST A RACIST, PLAIN AND SIMPLE.
i wouldn't say that radicalised black people are 'the problem' no i'd say that the race war agenda is just one plank of the over all agenda

i'd say that the radicalisation of black people is simply one head of the hydra that is currently trying to destroy the west

there are many other ways the cabal are trying to achieve their objective and i discuss those elsewhere on the forum

this thread though is about the fracture lines along the lines of race that the cabal are trying to deepen and widen

do i think racism by a white majority on a black minority is as much of a driver of the NWO as the use of mass immigration and radicalisation of people on the basis of ethnicity?

well put it this way...if a white person were to not employ a black person because of their ethnicity even though they were the best candidate then that would be ethically wrong but does it really forward the agenda of enslaving the whole of humanity under a nwo technocracy?

no it doesn't

but does the flooding in of poor unskilled immigrants and their radicalisation and mobilisation by the left so that they then politically support more immigration and the disarming of the population then advance the NWO agenda? yes it does

i mean that might sound quite cold but like i say try and imagine yourself as a martian looking down on all of this disspationately and you'll see what i'm saying is right...in the big picture
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act

Last edited by iamawaveofthesea; 23-02-2018 at 08:38 PM.
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:35 PM   #587
vancity eagle
Banned
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Posts: 10,492
Likes: 4,419 (2,496 Posts)
Default

[QUOTE]
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamawaveofthesea View Post
conservatism is basically about values like family, hard work and being law abiding
yes family values like "grabbing women by their pussies" having affairs with porn stars, telling your supporters to beat up opponents and how you will pay for their legal services, 2) Hard work like cheating on your taxes and not paying your share, ripping people off with Trump university, making money off of vices like GAMBLING, how conservative,3) Law abiding by invading and bombing other countries, threatening to steal their oil, killing families of terrorists, very law abiding.

No I think Conservatism actually has much darker aims but seeks to hide itself behind GOD and anything wholesome. Bullshit though. And conservatives prove themselves to be full of shit and hypocritical by voting for and supporting a monster like Trump.

Quote:
its foundations are built on christianity and the free markets which allow individual endevour, sponteneity and creativity
no its foundations are clearly built on race and class supremacy. That is what they want to CONSERVE. RACE AND CLASS SUPREMACY.

Quote:
this is why the cabal hate christianity and the free markets
The cabal love free markets, and they love fake Christians too, which The Republican party represents.

Quote:
its also why the cabal don't want the conservatives to own guns because they don't want free anything and don't want people to be able to protect their freedoms
Conservatives own tons of guns. The cabal haven't really done much to do anything otherwise.
Likes: (1)
vancity eagle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:46 PM   #588
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
yes family values like "grabbing women by their pussies" having affairs with porn stars, telling your supporters to beat up opponents and how you will pay for their legal services, 2) Hard work like cheating on your taxes and not paying your share, ripping people off with Trump university, making money off of vices like GAMBLING, how conservative,3) Law abiding by invading and bombing other countries, threatening to steal their oil, killing families of terrorists, very law abiding.
trump is not conservatism though is he?

trump is a boorish billionaire businessman

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
No I think Conservatism actually has much darker aims but seeks to hide itself behind GOD and anything wholesome. Bullshit though. And conservatives prove themselves to be full of shit and hypocritical by voting for and supporting a monster like Trump.
like i say i think the cabal will have its people in both camps

but the word 'conservative' means to conserve which is to manage change

by contrast the term 'progressive' denotes an intention to progress things to somewhere

so i'm concervative when i think the proposed change is a bad one and progressive when i like the proposed direction of change

so what i'm saying though is that the progressive agenda we are seeing is not really about making a better country but is in fact being steered by the cabal as a means of socially engineering a new society where the cabal will have total control over everyone

so to that plan i advocate a conservative approach!

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
no its foundations are clearly built on race and class supremacy. That is what they want to CONSERVE. RACE AND CLASS SUPREMACY.
that depends on the individual. Some black people might enjoy the free markets and might value family and community

of course the left is busy trying to tell them that the family is not necessary and that the state will take care of everything for them

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
The cabal love free markets, and they love fake Christians too, which The Republican party represents.
no the cabal love monopolies supported by the governments which they control

if they loved free markets then their banks wouldn't have been bailed out

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
Conservatives own tons of guns. The cabal haven't really done much to do anything otherwise.
that's why they are trying to change legislation so that they can take those guns off the public
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 08:56 PM   #589
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Liberal Professor says ‘Meritocracy’ is a Tool of Whiteness
Jeff Dunetz Jeff Dunetz January 9, 2018

Laurie Rubel, a math education professor at Brooklyn College published a paper in the Journal of Urban Mathematics Education contending that “meritocracy” in math classes is a “tool of whiteness.”

As someone who earned a barely passing 70 on his geometry regents, and who received a gift of a passing grade in trigonometry courtesy of the guys from Solomon Schechter in whose theft of the regents caused the test to be canceled, I would counter that eliminating meritocracy in math is simply absurd.
https://godfatherpolitics.com/libera...-of-whiteness/
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 09:02 PM   #590
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 09:09 PM   #591
vancity eagle
Banned
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Posts: 10,492
Likes: 4,419 (2,496 Posts)
Default

[QUOTE]
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamawaveofthesea View Post
trump is not conservatism though is he?

trump is a boorish billionaire businessman
Yes, but conservatives voted for and support him, showing that conservatives don't really give a fuck about GOD and wholesomeness. I would argue that conservatism is really about "white identity politics" which would explain why pretty much the vast majority of his supporters who claim to be "conservative" are white people.

Its white identity politics. Its not GOD and its not wholesomeness or family, its WHITE IDENTITY POLITICS.


Quote:
like i say i think the cabal will have its people in both camps

but the word 'conservative' means to conserve which is to manage change
Yes of course they want to manage change, BECAUSE THEY ALREADY RUN SHIT. Why on earth would they want change when they control everything.

Quote:
by contrast the term 'progressive' denotes an intention to progress things to somewhere

so i'm concervative when i think the proposed change is a bad one and progressive when i like the proposed direction of change
So do you think as a whole Society needs to CHANGE or STAY THE SAME ?

So if you want to "conserve" what we have, I take it you want to conserve the Rothschild system of domination we currently live under ?

Quote:
so what i'm saying though is that the progressive agenda we are seeing is not really about making a better country but is in fact being steered by the cabal as a means of socially engineering a new society where the cabal will have total control over everyone

so to that plan i advocate a conservative approach!
and the conservative agenda is not about conserving anything good but CONSSERVING THE STATUS QUO OF THE ELITES.
vancity eagle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 09:21 PM   #592
mranderson
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2013
Location: best planet in the Solar System
Posts: 3,742
Likes: 3,830 (1,980 Posts)
Default

[QUOTE=vancity eagle;1063002199]
Quote:

Yes, but conservatives voted for and support him, showing that conservatives don't really give a fuck about GOD and wholesomeness. I would argue that conservatism is really about "white identity politics" which would explain why pretty much the vast majority of his supporters who claim to be "conservative" are white people.

Its white identity politics. Its not GOD and its not wholesomeness or family, its WHITE IDENTITY POLITICS.




Yes of course they want to manage change, BECAUSE THEY ALREADY RUN SHIT. Why on earth would they want change when they control everything.



So do you think as a whole Society needs to CHANGE or STAY THE SAME ?

So if you want to "conserve" what we have, I take it you want to conserve the Rothschild system of domination we currently live under ?



and the conservative agenda is not about conserving anything good but CONSSERVING THE STATUS QUO OF THE ELITES.
no it is not white identity politics

people of all backgrounds voted for Trump and I have personally provided dozens of examples of this

but you will ignore them in favor of pushing the envelope
__________________
music sound and movement

They might drain the swamp but the snakes are still in the grass


It's symbolic of his struggle against reality
Likes: (1)
mranderson is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 09:25 PM   #593
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
Yes, but conservatives voted for and support him, showing that conservatives don't really give a fuck about GOD and wholesomeness. I would argue that conservatism is really about "white identity politics" which would explain why pretty much the vast majority of his supporters who claim to be "conservative" are white people.
did they vote for trump or did they vote against hilary?

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
Its white identity politics. Its not GOD and its not wholesomeness or family, its WHITE IDENTITY POLITICS.
then why did barak obama become president? people voted for him...but then people rejected what he and hilary had been doing for their 8 years in office which was destroying the american middle

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
Yes of course they want to manage change, BECAUSE THEY ALREADY RUN SHIT. Why on earth would they want change when they control everything.
no 'they' the conservative electorate don't run shit

the rothschild cabal run everything. they literally hold all the wealth

the conservative electorate don't want the cabal to change their republic into a socialist technocracy run by the cabal

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
So do you think as a whole Society needs to CHANGE or STAY THE SAME ?
what i'm asking is why aren't your primary concerns:

-family fragmentation

-vaccines with the CDC whistleblower having exposed that higher rates of autism occur in black boys after the MMR vaccine

-poverty that is pushed by the central banking system that is crushing communities

-rising racial tensions

-who is coming into the country and what the implications of that might be for regular folks

-what is in the chemtrails they are spraying us all with

-what they are intending to do with the 5G and SMART grid

instead you seem to worry about 'conservatives'

but conservatives aren't behind the things i mentioned above

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
So if you want to "conserve" what we have, I take it you want to conserve the Rothschild system of domination we currently live under ?
no i said i was conservative when i disagree with the change and progressive when i do agree with it

just because i reject what the rothschilds are offering through their marxist technocracy doesn't mean i think what we have now is the ideal

i just don't think that all change is good. I like to look BEFORE i leap

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
and the conservative agenda is not about conserving anything good but CONSSERVING THE STATUS QUO OF THE ELITES.
the el-ites have a lot of power at the moment and have grabbed most of the market share but they want to take things to a whole other level of control

that is why they are carrying out a revolution from above to radically alter society to their cashless digital currency society with implanted microchips and a smart grid lock down society

I think they are also working on bioweapons that are designed to target specific ethnicities. I think they are experimenting on those bioweapons in africa and elsewhere

that isn't conservatives doing that, it is the cabal and people like george soros and bill gates
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act

Last edited by iamawaveofthesea; 24-02-2018 at 12:46 PM.
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 10:47 PM   #594
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

an interesting perspective from david where he says we are all awareness having an experience in this reality and that all the increasing numbers of categories are about creating more and more distance between us and our true selves

__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 11:15 PM   #595
vancity eagle
Banned
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Posts: 10,492
Likes: 4,419 (2,496 Posts)
Default

[QUOTE=mranderson;1063002205]
Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post

no it is not white identity politics

people of all backgrounds voted for Trump and I have personally provided dozens of examples of this

but you will ignore them in favor of pushing the envelope
do you care to provide the racial makeup of Trump voters compared to Hillary voters ?

thanks in advance.
vancity eagle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23-02-2018, 11:26 PM   #596
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post
do you care to provide the racial makeup of Trump voters compared to Hillary voters ?

thanks in advance.
what was hilary offering black people?
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24-02-2018, 03:28 AM   #597
mranderson
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2013
Location: best planet in the Solar System
Posts: 3,742
Likes: 3,830 (1,980 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by vancity eagle View Post

do you care to provide the racial makeup of Trump voters compared to Hillary voters ?

thanks in advance.
No , because the truth is you don't care that people of all backgrounds voted the way they did

you only care that the satanic witch did not get to be the president

you and the rest of the Cabal

and don't bullshit me about the globalists wanting Trump to win as if it was some giant double bluff

the lengths and effort that went into getting Clinton in the Whitehouse are staggering

they even usurped the popular vote for Bernie Sanders to put her in place

you know that , I know that

and ever since that election announcement well the shit has hit the fan on the international stage

so much so we have a PMO in Canada calling people Nazis as well

which is very telling seeing as you were also throwing that word around like confetti days after the election

all to distract from the EPIC amounts of information all ready collected by citizens on the crimes of the globalists

your beloved non president Clinton is up to her tits in scandal , and so is anyone else who tried their best to subvert a democratic election in the USA

you played your hands too soon comrade

big mistake
__________________
music sound and movement

They might drain the swamp but the snakes are still in the grass


It's symbolic of his struggle against reality
mranderson is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25-02-2018, 12:28 AM   #598
iamawaveofthesea
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 26,740
Likes: 13,667 (7,885 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by iamawaveofthesea View Post
The politicisation of science to justify IDEOLOGICALLY DRIVEN social engineering

A quick search about the archeologist Tom Booth shows that he has written about the politicisation of science in the wake of the brexit vote (see link below to read his views). But how assured can we be that Tom is impartial and not himself politicising science?

It seems to me that what he wants to do is undermine any claim that existing inhabitants of the british isles have to this land. However if we go back far enough can we use arguments about distant migrations as an excuse to displace ANY people around the world after all if we go back far enough then EVERYONE is an immigrant

So really we have to look at this whole-istically to consider all factors such as folk-memory, language, beliefs, values, culture, architecture, art, traditions, sports, cuisine and so on to take in the fuller picture of what makes up a national population and its sense of identity

Then besides all of these issues there are pragmatic questions to be asked about the ECONOMIC sense in importing millions of poor and unskilled migrants into what is an already over crowded geographic locale

So what we are seeing in the media and in education is people wriggling this way and that to constantly find excuses for why they want to ethnically cleanse british people and to justify their own IDEOLOGICAL ideas of how society should be socially engineered and you have to wonder how much of all of this activity is funded by the rothschild-cabal...

Response to ‘Brexit, Archaeology and Heritage: Reflections and Agendas’
Authors: Lorna-Jane Richardson ,Tom Booth
https://pia-journal.co.uk/articles/10.5334/pia-545/
Ancient ‘dark-skinned’ Briton Cheddar Man find may not be true
21 February 2018
By Colin Barras

A Briton who lived 10,000 years ago had dark brown skin and blue eyes. At least, that’s what dozens of news stories published this month – including our own – stated as fact. But one of the geneticists who performed the research says the conclusion is less certain, and according to others we are not even close to knowing the skin colour of any ancient human.

The skeleton of Cheddar Man was discovered in 1903 in a cave in south-west England where it had lain for 10,000 years. …
https://www.newscientist.com/article...y-not-be-true/
__________________
when the people in power want you dead, just existing is a revolutionary act
iamawaveofthesea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25-02-2018, 01:15 AM   #599
georgesmiley
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Land of the Flea
Posts: 2,132
Likes: 795 (402 Posts)
Default

access to the full new scientist article is available to paying subscribers only - sadly.
georgesmiley is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25-02-2018, 02:09 AM   #600
metak88
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 232 (150 Posts)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by georgesmiley View Post
access to the full new scientist article is available to paying subscribers only - sadly.
Not the original article, but has more info than the original behind pay-wall.
http://newobserveronline.com/black-s...tist-magazine/


Quote:
“Black-Skinned” Cheddar Man Claims Untrue, Admits New Scientist Magazine
TNO Staff — February 23, 2018 1 comment
Recent claims that Britain’s “Cheddar Man” had “black skin” are not true, there is “no confidence in the DNA analysis” and there is currently no fool-proof way to predict the skin color of bodies from ancient skeletons, New Scientist magazine has admitted.

“We cannot place such confidence in the DNA analysis,” the magazine quoted Susan Walsh, the scientist whose theoretical model was used to “prove” that Cheddar man was “black.”



In an article titled “Ancient ‘dark-skinned’ Briton Cheddar Man find may not be true” (21 February 2018), the New Scientist—one of the world’s most famous scientific journals, published continuously since 1956—the publication admitted that the claims about Britain’s oldest complete Cro-Magnon skeleton were untrue.

When the “news” was first announced—to coincide with a UK TV show of the research (called the “The First Briton”), the claim that Cheddar Man had black skin was widely trumpeted as “proof” that the “first Britons” were in fact black.

This claim has since been used ad nauseam by the controlled media and race-denying leftists to claim that there are no “indigenous people” in Europe, all to justify the mass Third World invasion of that continent which is currently under way.

All informed observers knew straight away that there was something wrong with this news, particularly because previous DNA testing on the skeleton had shown that his mitochondrial DNA was European (haplogroup U5a, to be exact, the same lineage as 11 percent of all present-day Europeans, as detailed in Sykes, Bryan, Blood of the Isles, Bantam, 2006).

Now however, the New Scientist has admitted that “one of the geneticists who performed the research says the conclusion is less certain, and according to others we are not even close to knowing the skin colour of any ancient human.”

According to the magazine, researchers used a skin color prediction model developed by Susan Walsh at Indiana University–Purdue University Indianapolis to make the claim that Cheddar Man’s skin color was black.

As the New Scientist explained:

To test it, Walsh and her colleagues took genetic data from over 1400 people, mainly from Europe and the US but also some from Africa and Papua New Guinea.

The team used part of the data to “train” their model on how skin colour and the 36 DNA markers are linked. They then used the rest of the data to test how well the model could predict skin colour from DNA alone.

The model correctly identified who had “light” skin or “dark-black” skin, with a small margin of error.

When Walsh and her colleagues applied the model to Cheddar Man, they concluded his skin colour fell between “dark” and “dark to black”.

Walsh stresses that the study doesn’t conclusively demonstrate Cheddar Man had dark to black skin.

“We cannot place such confidence in the DNA analysis,” she says.

For one thing, Cheddar Man’s DNA has degraded over the last 10,000 years.

“It’s not a simple statement of ‘this person was dark-skinned’,” says Walsh.


The New Scientist then went on to admit that scientists are “not ready to predict the skin colour of prehistoric people just from their genes.”

Quoting Brenna Henn at Stony Brook University, New York, whose work on the topic is widely known in the scientific world, the reason for this is because “the genetics of skin pigmentation turn out to be more complex than thought.”

The New Scientist explained that Henn and her colleagues had published a paper in November 2017 “exploring the genetics of skin pigmentation in populations indigenous to southern Africa—where skin colour varies more than many people appreciate.”

As the New Scientist explained:

Just weeks before, a group led by Sarah Tishkoff at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia had published a paper on the genetics of skin pigmentation in people from eastern and southern Africa.

“The conclusions were really the same,” says Henn. “Known skin pigmentation genes, discovered primarily in East Asian and European populations, don’t explain the variation in skin pigmentation in African populations. The idea that there are really only about 15 genes underlying skin pigmentation isn’t correct.”

It now seems likely that many other genes affect skin colour. We don’t know how.

If we are still learning about the link between genes and skin pigmentation in living populations, we can’t yet predict the skin colour of prehistoric people, says Henn.

Walsh’s model might succeed at this in the US, says Henn, because it was trained on DNA from people with similar ancestry to North Americans. But it may well fail elsewhere.

Henn’s team has tested an older model that aimed to predict skin colour from DNA.

When they put it to work among southern African populations, “it literally predicted that people with the darkest skins would have the lightest skin.”

The original paper upon which the Cheddar Man claims (“Population Replacement in Early Neolithic Britain”) were made has now been published by the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Preprint Server for Biology, from where it can be seen that the claims do indeed rely on Walsh’s theoretical model—which she herself said was not reliable.

The paper’s relevant part reads:

We predicted pigmentation characteristics for Cheddar Man using Hirisplex (Walsh, S. et al. Developmental validation of the HIrisplex system: DNA-based eye and hair colour prediction for forensic and anthropological useage. Forensic Sci. Int. Genet. 9, 150-161 (2014)) and a recently-developed method for predicting skin pigmentation (Walsh, S. et al. Global skin colour prediction from DNA. Human Genetics 136, 847–863 (2017)).

The paper admits that

“Previously, predictions on the level of skin pigmentation were mostly derived using two SNPs in SLC45A2 and SLC24A5 that indicate lack of hypo-pigmentation when in the ancestral state (Olalde, I. et al. Derived immune and ancestral pigmentation alleles in a 7,000-year old Mesolithic European. Nature 507, 225–228 (2014)).

“Hypopigmentation” is the scientific term for the “loss of skin color”—or in this case, very pale skin color.
__________________
In rehab...
metak88 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:59 PM.


Shoutbox provided by vBShout (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2019 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.